Productivity · head to head
Memberstack vs Productive

Memberstack
Productivity
Add memberships and logins to any website
- From
- Free
- Free plan
- Yes

Productive
Professional Services
Run projects, budgets and resources in one place
- From
- $10/month
- Free plan
- No
The short version
- Memberstack has a free plan, then $29/mo; Productive starts at $10/mo.
- Where Memberstack falls short: basic and Professional tiers include transaction fees of 4% and 2% respectively.
- Where Productive falls short: essential plan is capped at 5 account-level custom fields and 1 CRM pipeline versus 15 fields and 3 pipelines on Professional.
- Prices and features on this page were last checked on 13 November 2026.
Where they differ
Only the attributes on which Memberstack and Productive actually diverge.
| Attribute | Memberstack | Productive |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | Free | $10/month |
| Free tier | Yes | No |
| Category | Productivity | Professional Services |
Identical on both: pricing model (Subscription), platforms (Web).
What people use each for
The jobs each tool is most often brought in to do.
Memberstack
- Launching course platforms without custom backendnot Productive
- Building subscription services with Webflow and paymentnot Productive
- Gating content without writing codenot Productive
- Managing password resets and two-factor authenticationnot Productive
- Processing Stripe billing automaticallynot Productive
Productive
- Team resource planningnot Memberstack
- Project and expense managementnot Memberstack
- Time tracking and invoicingnot Memberstack
Where each one falls short
Documented limitations, not opinions. Every one is a constraint you would hit in normal use.
Memberstack
- Basic and Professional tiers include transaction fees of 4% and 2% respectively
- Annual billing required for discounts; monthly pricing is higher
- Webflow community builders receive Basic plan free but locked to that tier
Productive
- Essential plan is capped at 5 account-level custom fields and 1 CRM pipeline versus 15 fields and 3 pipelines on Professional
- Ultimate tier for complex organizations is quote-only, listed as Let's talk with no published price
Pricing, plan by plan
Memberstack
Free- Basic$29/mo
- Up to 1,000 members
- 4% transaction fee
- $25/month with annual billing
- Professional$49/mo
- Up to 5,000 members
- 2% transaction fee
- $39/month with annual billing
- Business$99/mo
- 10,000+ members
- 0.9% transaction fee
- $79/month with annual billing
- Established$499/mo
- 10,000+ members
- Zero transaction fees
- $399/month with annual billing
Productive
$10/month- Essential$10/mo
- Budgeting
- Resource planning
- Project and task management
- Essential Annual$12/mo
- All Essential features (billed annually at 20% discount)
- Professional$25/mo
- All Essential features
- HRIS and Invoicing integrations
- Recurring budgets
- UltimateOn request
- All Professional features
- Revenue forecasting
- Scenario Builder
Which should you pick?
Choose Productive if
Nothing in the data separates Productive from Memberstack on the points above - pick on price and on how each one feels to use.
Questions people ask
- Is Memberstack or Productive better?
- Neither clearly leads. Memberstack starts at Free and Productive at $10/month, and user ratings are close enough to be indistinguishable. Choose on capability and platform support.
- Which is cheaper, Memberstack or Productive?
- Memberstack has a free tier; the other does not. Paid plans start at Free for Memberstack and $10/month for Productive.
- Does Memberstack or Productive run on more platforms?
- Both run on Web, so platform support will not decide this one for you.
- Can I use Memberstack for free?
- Yes. Memberstack has a free tier, so you can try it without paying. Productive starts at $10/month.
- What is Memberstack best used for?
- Memberstack is most often used for launching course platforms without custom backend, building subscription services with webflow and payment, gating content without writing code, managing password resets and two-factor authentication. Of those, launching course platforms without custom backend and building subscription services with webflow and payment are not what Productive is typically brought in for.
Answered from the vendors’ own pages
Memberstack: What are Memberstack's transaction fees?
Memberstack's transaction fee varies by tier: Basic plan charges 4% per transaction, Professional charges 2%, Business charges 0.9%, and Established tier charges zero transaction fees.
SourceProductive: How much does Productive cost per month?
The Essential plan starts at $10/user/month (or $12/user/month billed annually). The Professional plan costs $25/user/month. Pricing is per user, so multiply by team size.
SourceMemberstack: Does Memberstack offer a free trial or testing mode?
Yes, Memberstack offers an unlimited free trial in test mode requiring no credit card. Users maintain full feature access at no cost until their site launches with real members.
SourceProductive: Does Productive offer a free trial?
Free trial information is not displayed on the pricing page. Contact their sales team via the website for trial availability and custom Ultimate plan pricing.
SourceMemberstack: What discounts does Memberstack offer?
Memberstack offers 50% discount for non-profits, special pricing for young professionals (4% fees), and $249/month with zero fees for startups under $1M raised. Webflow community builders receive the Basic plan free. 30-day money-back guarantee available with full refund.
SourceProductive: What features does the Essential plan include?
The Essential plan includes budgeting, resource planning, project and task management, time tracking, expense management, reporting, time off management, and API access with 5 custom fields.
SourceProductive: What is the difference between Professional and Ultimate plans?
The Professional plan includes HRIS integrations, advanced reports, and team collaboration tools at $25/user/month. Ultimate adds revenue forecasting, scenario builder, multiple subsidiaries, and custom integrations at custom pricing.
SourceRelated pages
More on Memberstack
Other head to heads
- Memberstack vs Notion
- Memberstack vs Todoist
- Memberstack vs OmniFocus 3
- Memberstack vs Hubstaff
- Memberstack vs Paprika Recipe Manager
- Memberstack vs Remember The Milk
- Memberstack vs Tana
- Memberstack vs Gamma
- Memberstack vs Lazy
- Memberstack vs FigJam
- Memberstack vs Alfred
- Memberstack vs Milanote
- Memberstack vs tldraw
- Memberstack vs Ulysses
- Memberstack vs Anvil
- Memberstack vs WPS Office
- Memberstack vs Xmind
- Memberstack vs Yap
- Memberstack vs Accelo
- Memberstack vs Certinia PSA
- Memberstack vs FreshBooks
- Memberstack vs TravelPerk
- Memberstack vs Bonsai
- Memberstack vs Avaza
- Memberstack vs Function Point
- Memberstack vs Plutio
- Memberstack vs Harvest
- Memberstack vs Toggl Track
- Memberstack vs Wave
- Memberstack vs BigTime
- Memberstack vs Hiveage
- Memberstack vs Kantata
- Memberstack vs Scoro
- Memberstack vs Teamwork
- Memberstack vs Freelancer.com
- Memberstack vs Guru
- Productive vs Notion
- Productive vs Todoist
- Productive vs OmniFocus 3
- Productive vs Hubstaff
- Productive vs Paprika Recipe Manager
- Productive vs Remember The Milk
- Productive vs Tana
- Productive vs Gamma
- Productive vs Lazy
- Productive vs FigJam
- Productive vs Alfred
- Productive vs Milanote
- Productive vs tldraw
- Productive vs Ulysses
- Productive vs Anvil
- Productive vs WPS Office
- Productive vs Xmind
- Productive vs Yap
- Productive vs Accelo
- Productive vs Certinia PSA
- Productive vs FreshBooks
- Productive vs TravelPerk
- Productive vs Bonsai
- Productive vs Avaza
- Productive vs Function Point
- Productive vs Plutio
- Productive vs Harvest
- Productive vs Toggl Track
- Productive vs Wave
- Productive vs BigTime
- Productive vs Hiveage
- Productive vs Kantata
- Productive vs Scoro
- Productive vs Teamwork
- Productive vs Freelancer.com
- Productive vs Guru
