Softwr

Customer Success · head to head

SmartKarrot vs Zip

SmartKarrot logo

SmartKarrot

Customer Success

Intelligent Customer Success Platform

From
$15000/year
Free plan
No
Zip logo

Zip

ERP

Procurement intake and orchestration that sits on top of the systems you already run

From
On request
Free plan
No

The short version

  • SmartKarrot is an intelligent customer success platform.
  • SmartKarrot starts at $15000/yr; Zip prices on request.
  • Only SmartKarrot lists customer 360; only Zip lists unified intake.
  • Where SmartKarrot falls short: the entry Basic plan starts at $15,000 per year and includes only 5 users.
  • Where Zip falls short: pricing is not published and is structured around company size and integration scope, so buyers cannot benchmark without peer references.
  • Prices and features on this page were last checked on 20 November 2026.

How do SmartKarrot and Zip differ?

SmartKarrot and Zip differ on starting price ($15000/year against On request), pricing model (Subscription against Quote) and platforms (Web against Web, iOS). Only the attributes on which SmartKarrot and Zip actually diverge.

Attributes where SmartKarrot and Zip differ
AttributeSmartKarrotZip
Starting price$15000/yearOn request
Pricing modelSubscriptionQuote
PlatformsWebWeb, iOS
CategoryCustomer SuccessERP
Founded20182020

Identical on both: free tier (No).

Which features does each one have?

They share no listed features; 10 appear only for SmartKarrot and 8 only for Zip. Drawn from each product's published feature list. An absence here means we hold no record of it - not that the product lacks it.

Only in SmartKarrot

  • Customer 360
  • Health monitoring
  • Playbook automation
  • Success planning
  • Touchpoints tracking
  • Salesforce
  • HubSpot
  • Slack

Only in Zip

  • Unified intake
  • Approval orchestration
  • Vendor onboarding
  • Contract repository
  • ERP write-back
  • Renewal management
  • Spend visibility
  • AI request handling

What is each one used for?

SmartKarrot is most often brought in for tracking customer onboarding phases and account health for a SaaS business. The jobs each tool is most often brought in to do.

SmartKarrot

  • Tracking customer onboarding phases and account health for a SaaS businessnot Zip
  • Segmenting accounts and users to target customer success playsnot Zip
  • Reporting on customer success outcomes with embedded BI dashboardsnot Zip

Zip

  • A company that owns a source-to-pay suite nobody uses because employees cannot navigate itnot SmartKarrot
  • An organisation where every software purchase needs security, legal, privacy and finance sign-off and currently does it in email threadsnot SmartKarrot
  • A finance team that keeps discovering contracts that auto-renewed because nobody owned the renewal datenot SmartKarrot
  • A business needing an auditable record of who approved a third-party engagement and on what evidencenot SmartKarrot

Where do SmartKarrot and Zip fall short?

SmartKarrot's most cited limit: the entry Basic plan starts at $15,000 per year and includes only 5 users. Documented limitations, not opinions. Every one is a constraint you would hit in normal use.

SmartKarrot

  • The entry Basic plan starts at $15,000 per year and includes only 5 users
  • All plans are billed annually with no monthly option
  • Basic includes only 2 third party integrations, Growth 3 and Pro 4
  • Usage tracking is limited to 1 SaaS product on Growth and 3 on Pro
  • Growth, Pro and Enterprise plans are all Contact Sales with no published price
  • Basic support is email-based only, with a dedicated CSM starting at Growth
  • SmartKonversation call intelligence is a paid add-on rather than an included feature on Basic, Growth or Pro
  • SmartOps advanced AI trends is an add-on available only on the Enterprise plan
  • Additional Lite users are billed at $10 per user per month on top of the plan fee

Zip

  • It is a layer on top of systems you already pay for, so the business case rests on adoption and cycle time rather than replacing a licence, and that is harder to defend to a finance director cutting software spend
  • Value depends entirely on integration depth into your specific ERP and ticketing tools, and a shallow connector reduces it to a workflow tool that someone rekeys out of
  • Pricing is not published and is structured around company size and integration scope, so buyers cannot benchmark without peer references
  • If procurement policy itself is unclear, Zip encodes the confusion: the tool routes requests according to rules someone must first write, and organisations without that clarity see slow implementations
  • It does not do sourcing, auctions or spend analysis, so organisations expecting a full procurement capability will still need a suite or specialist tools alongside it

How much do SmartKarrot and Zip cost?

SmartKarrot starts at $15000/yr; Zip is priced on request. Plan by plan below, from each vendor's own pricing page.

SmartKarrot

$15000/year
  • Basic$15,000/yr
    • 5 included users
    • CRM functionality
    • Email and calendar integration
  • GrowthOn request
    • 10 included users
    • All Basic features
    • 1 SaaS product tracking
  • ProOn request
    • 25 included users
    • All Growth features
    • 3 SaaS products
  • EnterpriseOn request
    • Custom user count
    • Unlimited customization
    • 3+ SaaS products

Zip

On request
  • ZipOn request
    • Intake and approval orchestration
    • Vendor onboarding and diligence workflows
    • Integrations with ERP, contract and ticketing systems

Which should you pick?

Choose SmartKarrot if

  • You need customer 360.
  • You also want health monitoring.

Choose Zip if

  • You need unified intake.
  • You work on Web, iOS.
  • You also want approval orchestration.

Questions people ask

Is SmartKarrot or Zip better?
Neither clearly leads. SmartKarrot starts at $15000/year and Zip at On request, and user ratings are close enough to be indistinguishable. Choose on capability and platform support.
Which is cheaper, SmartKarrot or Zip?
SmartKarrot starts at $15000/year and Zip at On request.
Does SmartKarrot or Zip run on more platforms?
SmartKarrot runs on Web. Zip runs on Web, iOS.
What is SmartKarrot best used for?
SmartKarrot is most often used for tracking customer onboarding phases and account health for a saas business, segmenting accounts and users to target customer success plays, reporting on customer success outcomes with embedded bi dashboards. Of those, tracking customer onboarding phases and account health for a saas business and segmenting accounts and users to target customer success plays are not what Zip is typically brought in for.
What can SmartKarrot do that Zip cannot?
SmartKarrot covers Customer 360, Health monitoring, Playbook automation, Success planning. Zip covers Unified intake, Approval orchestration, Vendor onboarding, Contract repository.

Answered from the vendors’ own pages

SmartKarrot: How much does SmartKarrot cost?

SmartKarrot's Basic plan costs $15,000 per year for 5 included users with CRM, email and calendar integration, and 2 third-party integrations. Growth and Pro plans require contacting sales for pricing. Enterprise plans are customized based on organizational requirements.

Source
Zip: Is this the buy now pay later company?

No. This is Zip at ziphq.com, a procurement orchestration platform, unrelated to the payments company of the same name.

SmartKarrot: What support is included in SmartKarrot plans?

The Basic plan includes email-based support only. Growth and Pro plans include a dedicated customer success manager. Enterprise plans offer premium support tier with customized support levels.

Source
Zip: Does it replace Coupa or Ariba?

No, and that is the point. It sits in front of them, providing the intake and approval experience employees actually use, and writes back into the suite.

SmartKarrot: What are SmartKarrot's add-on services?

SmartKarrot offers optional enhancements including SmartKonversation (call intelligence), SmartOps (AI-powered trend analysis), and embedded business intelligence for reporting. These add-ons are available across plan tiers.

Source
Zip: What does it cost?

Not published. Quoted by company size, modules and the integrations you need. Get peer benchmarks before negotiating.

Zip: What is the prerequisite for success?

A written procurement policy. Zip automates the routing rules you give it; if nobody can say who approves what, implementation stalls.

Share

Related pages

Other head to heads