Softwr

Fitness · head to head

StrongLifts vs Tonal

StrongLifts logo

StrongLifts

Fitness

5x5 barbell strength training app built around a fixed beginner programme, sold as a subscription

From
Free
Rated
-
Full reviewWebsite
Tonal logo

Tonal

Fitness

The world's smartest home gym

From
$59.95/month
Rated
-
Full reviewWebsite

The short version

  • Only StrongLifts has a free tier, so it costs nothing to try first.
  • Each has a real cost: StrongLifts it is built around one specific programme, so once a lifter progresses beyond what 5x5 is designed for and stalls, the app's core structure no longer fits their needs and they typically need a different programme entirely.; Tonal subscription is mandatory with equipment purchase
  • They diverge on capability: StrongLifts covers 5x5 programme tracking, Tonal covers Digital weight system.
  • Prices and features above were last checked on 1 September 2026.

Where they differ

Only the attributes on which StrongLifts and Tonal actually diverge.

Attributes where StrongLifts and Tonal differ
AttributeStrongLiftsTonal
Starting priceFree$59.95/month
Pricing modelFree tier plus subscriptionsubscription
Free tierYesNo
PlatformsiOS, AndroidProprietary hardware
FoundedUnknown2015

Identical on both: user rating (Not yet rated), category (Fitness).

What each one covers

Drawn from each product's published feature list. An absence here means we hold no record of it - not that the product lacks it.

Only in StrongLifts

  • 5x5 programme tracking
  • Automatic progression
  • Plate calculator
  • Rest timer
  • Form videos
  • Workout history

Only in Tonal

  • Digital weight system
  • AI-powered training
  • Form feedback
  • Personalized programs
  • Strength assessment
  • Apple Health
  • Apple Watch
  • Ios support

What people use each for

The jobs each tool is most often brought in to do.

StrongLifts

  • A beginner lifter wanting a structured, proven barbell programme rather than designing their ownnot Tonal
  • Someone wanting automatic weight progression calculated for them rather than manually tracking increasesnot Tonal
  • A lifter wanting a plate calculator to avoid mental maths loading a barbellnot Tonal
  • Someone following 5x5 specifically who wants form videos built into the tracking appnot Tonal

Tonal

  • Home fitness with digital strength trainingnot StrongLifts
  • Personal workout customization and trackingnot StrongLifts
  • Recovery monitoring and adaptationnot StrongLifts
  • HSA/FSA eligible fitness equipmentnot StrongLifts

Where each one falls short

Documented limitations, not opinions. Every one is a constraint you would hit in normal use.

StrongLifts

  • It is built around one specific programme, so once a lifter progresses beyond what 5x5 is designed for and stalls, the app's core structure no longer fits their needs and they typically need a different programme entirely.
  • Full functionality requires a paid subscription, and the free tier is limited enough that serious use of the programme effectively requires paying.
  • It offers little flexibility for customising exercises or set schemes compared with general-purpose workout loggers, since flexibility is not the point of the product.
  • 5x5 as a method is not suited to every body or goal, for example it is not designed for hypertrophy-focused or advanced lifters, and the app does not steer users away from it once it stops being appropriate.
  • Subscription billing continues after a user has outgrown the programme unless actively cancelled, which is a common pattern across fitness app subscriptions generally.

Tonal

  • Subscription is mandatory with equipment purchase
  • Rental program requires credit approval
  • Not available as rent-to-own option
  • Higher barrier to entry compared to traditional gym equipment
  • Financing options mentioned but rates not detailed

Pricing, plan by plan

StrongLifts

Free
  • FreeFree
    • Limited programme access and logging
  • StrongLifts Premium$undefined/month
    • Full 5x5 programme access
    • Custom plate settings
    • Expanded workout history and stats

Tonal

$59.95/month
  • Standard Membership$59.95/month
    • Required with Tonal 2 purchase
    • 12-month commitment
    • Access to Tonal system
  • Tonal 2 Rental$219/month
    • First 3 months promotional pricing
    • Delivery and installation included
    • Monthly membership
  • Tonal 1 Certified Refurbished Rental$159/month
    • First 3 months promotional pricing
    • Delivery and installation included
    • Reduces to $219/month after 3 months

Which should you pick?

Choose StrongLifts if

  • You need 5x5 programme tracking.
  • You want to start without paying.
  • You work on iOS, Android.
  • You also want automatic progression.
StrongLifts review

Choose Tonal if

  • You need digital weight system.
  • You work on Proprietary hardware.
  • You also want ai-powered training.
Tonal review

Questions people ask

Is StrongLifts or Tonal better?
Neither clearly leads. StrongLifts starts at Free and Tonal at $59.95/month, and user ratings are close enough to be indistinguishable. Choose on capability and platform support.
Which is cheaper, StrongLifts or Tonal?
StrongLifts has a free tier; the other does not. Paid plans start at Free for StrongLifts and $59.95/month for Tonal.
Does StrongLifts or Tonal run on more platforms?
StrongLifts runs on iOS, Android. Tonal runs on Proprietary hardware.
Can I use StrongLifts for free?
Yes. StrongLifts has a free tier, so you can try it without paying. Tonal starts at $59.95/month.
What is StrongLifts best used for?
StrongLifts is most often used for a beginner lifter wanting a structured, proven barbell programme rather than designing their own, someone wanting automatic weight progression calculated for them rather than manually tracking increases, a lifter wanting a plate calculator to avoid mental maths loading a barbell, someone following 5x5 specifically who wants form videos built into the tracking app. Of those, a beginner lifter wanting a structured, proven barbell programme rather than designing their own and someone wanting automatic weight progression calculated for them rather than manually tracking increases are not what Tonal is typically brought in for.
What can StrongLifts do that Tonal cannot?
StrongLifts covers 5x5 programme tracking, Automatic progression, Plate calculator, Rest timer. Tonal covers Digital weight system, AI-powered training, Form feedback, Personalized programs.

Answered from the vendors’ own pages

StrongLifts: Is StrongLifts free?

There is a free tier with limited access; full programme features require a paid subscription.

Tonal: What is the cost of Tonal's Standard Membership?

Standard Membership costs $59.95 per month plus applicable sales tax and is required when purchasing a Tonal 2 machine with a 12-month commitment.

Source
StrongLifts: Is this the same as the Strong app?

No, Strong is a general-purpose workout logger for any routine; StrongLifts is built specifically around the 5x5 programme.

Tonal: Can I rent a Tonal machine instead of buying it?

Yes, Tonal offers rental programs. Tonal 2 rents for $219/month for the first 3 months (then $279/month), and Tonal 1 Certified Refurbished rents for $159/month for the first 3 months (then $219/month). All rental prices include delivery and installation.

Source
StrongLifts: Who is 5x5 suited for?

Primarily beginner to early-intermediate lifters building a strength base; it is not designed as a long-term or advanced programme.

Tonal: Does Tonal accept HSA or FSA payments?

Yes, Tonal is eligible for payment through HSA (Health Savings Account) and FSA (Flexible Spending Account) via TrueMed.

Source
Tonal: Is Tonal available as a rent-to-own option?

No, Tonal explicitly clarifies that rental programs are not rent-to-own arrangements. Rental is a separate option from purchasing equipment.

Source
Share

Related pages

More on StrongLifts

More on Tonal

Keep looking

Other head to heads