Softwr

APIs · head to head

Formance vs Amazon Redshift ML

Formance logo

Formance

APIs

Open source double-entry ledger and payment orchestration for money-moving software

From
Free
Free plan
Yes
Amazon Redshift ML logo

Amazon Redshift ML

Machine Learning

SQL statements in Redshift that train models on SageMaker and return them as functions

From
Free
Free plan
Yes

The short version

  • Formance is an MIT-licensed double-entry ledger.
  • Formance is free; Amazon Redshift ML starts at $0.25/mo.
  • Only Formance lists double-entry ledger; only Amazon Redshift ML lists CREATE MODEL in SQL.
  • Prices and features on this page were last checked on 20 November 2026.

How do Formance and Amazon Redshift ML differ?

Formance and Amazon Redshift ML differ on pricing model, platforms and category (APIs against Machine Learning). Only the attributes on which Formance and Amazon Redshift ML actually diverge.

Attributes where Formance and Amazon Redshift ML differ
AttributeFormanceAmazon Redshift ML
Pricing modelOpen source, no licence feeUsage-based
PlatformsLinux, Self-hosted, Web, APIWeb
CategoryAPIsMachine Learning

Identical on both: starting price (Free), free tier (Yes).

Not yet recorded: founded for Formance.

Which features does each one have?

They share no listed features; 8 appear only for Formance and 8 only for Amazon Redshift ML. Drawn from each product's published feature list. An absence here means we hold no record of it - not that the product lacks it.

Only in Formance

  • Double-entry ledger
  • Numscript transaction DSL
  • Multi-currency
  • Payments connectivity
  • Reconciliation
  • Self-hosted deployment
  • Cloud offering
  • API and SDKs

Only in Amazon Redshift ML

  • CREATE MODEL in SQL
  • Automatic model selection
  • Local inference
  • Bring your own model
  • Algorithm selection
  • Cost ceiling controls
  • Existing warehouse security
  • Batch and interactive scoring

What is each one used for?

The jobs each tool is most often brought in to do.

Formance

  • A marketplace splitting a single customer payment between seller, platform fee and tax that needs the split to be atomic and auditablenot Amazon Redshift ML
  • A fintech whose homegrown balances table produced numbers finance could not reconcile and now needs proper double-entry before an auditnot Amazon Redshift ML
  • A payments team that wants one normalised model across several PSPs so reconciliation is not written separately for eachnot Amazon Redshift ML
  • A company that wants its ledger under a licence it can keep running even if the vendor disappearsnot Amazon Redshift ML

Amazon Redshift ML

  • Adding a churn or propensity score to an existing dashboard where the data is already in Redshift and nobody needs a bespoke modelnot Formance
  • Letting an analytics team test whether a predictive column has any business value before asking for data science headcountnot Formance
  • Scoring rows inside a SQL pipeline where moving data out to a separate service would add fragility for little benefitnot Formance
  • Organisations committed to AWS whose main constraint is a data science backlog rather than modelling sophisticationnot Formance

Where do Formance and Amazon Redshift ML fall short?

Documented limitations, not opinions. Every one is a constraint you would hit in normal use.

Formance

  • Formance holds no money and provides no regulatory cover, so it must be paired with a payments provider or bank, and buyers occasionally mistake a ledger for a treasury system and discover the gap late
  • Numscript is a domain-specific language your team must learn, and while it makes complex splits expressible it also means transaction logic sits outside the languages your engineers already debug well
  • Self-hosting a ledger that must never lose or duplicate a transaction is a serious operational commitment covering backups, upgrades and Postgres tuning, which is real cost the zero licence fee hides
  • Enterprise pricing is not published, so the difference between the free path and the supported path cannot be evaluated without a sales conversation
  • The company is much smaller than the incumbent alternatives, and while the MIT licence protects the code it does not protect the roadmap, so features on the hosted side may arrive slowly or change direction

Amazon Redshift ML

  • Training is billed by SageMaker separately from Redshift, so a feature that looks like a free SQL statement produces a second line item on a different part of the bill that the analyst who ran it usually cannot see
  • Autopilot searches many candidate models by default and the duration and cost of CREATE MODEL scale with the data size and the MAX_CELLS setting, so an unconstrained statement against a large table is an expensive accident rather than an experiment
  • Local inference runs on the Redshift cluster itself, so scoring millions of rows competes for the resources the warehouse exists to provide, and the remote inference alternative adds a per-batch network call plus an hourly SageMaker endpoint charge that persists whether or not anyone queries it
  • The supported problem types are limited to what the exposed algorithms cover, so anything involving text, images, sequences, a custom loss function or a bespoke evaluation metric is out of scope and has to be built conventionally
  • There is no retraining schedule, drift detection or model registry, so a model created by a statement stays exactly as trained until somebody remembers to recreate it, and nothing in the warehouse will report that its accuracy has decayed

How much do Formance and Amazon Redshift ML cost?

Formance is free to use; Amazon Redshift ML has a free plan, with paid plans from $0.25/mo. Plan by plan below, from each vendor's own pricing page.

Formance

Free
  • Open SourceFree
    • MIT licensed core ledger
    • Numscript transaction DSL
    • Multi-currency tracking
  • EnterpriseOn request
    • Managed or private deployment
    • Payments connectivity and reconciliation
    • Support with response commitments

Amazon Redshift ML

Free
  • Free TrialFree
    • 2-month trial
    • 750 DC2.Large hours
  • On-Demand$0.25/hour
    • Per-node pricing
    • SageMaker training

Which should you pick?

Choose Formance if

  • You need double-entry ledger.
  • You want to start without paying.
  • You work on Linux, Self-hosted, Web, API.
  • You also want numscript transaction dsl.

Choose Amazon Redshift ML if

  • You need create model in sql.
  • You want to start without paying.
  • You also want automatic model selection.

Questions people ask

Is Formance or Amazon Redshift ML better?
Neither clearly leads. Formance starts at Free and Amazon Redshift ML at Free, and user ratings are close enough to be indistinguishable. Choose on capability and platform support.
Which is cheaper, Formance or Amazon Redshift ML?
Formance starts at Free and Amazon Redshift ML at Free.
Does Formance or Amazon Redshift ML run on more platforms?
Formance runs on Linux, Self-hosted, Web, API. Amazon Redshift ML runs on Web.
Can I use Formance for free?
Both have a free tier, so you can try either at no cost before committing.
What is Formance best used for?
Formance is most often used for a marketplace splitting a single customer payment between seller, platform fee and tax that needs the split to be atomic and auditable, a fintech whose homegrown balances table produced numbers finance could not reconcile and now needs proper double-entry before an audit, a payments team that wants one normalised model across several psps so reconciliation is not written separately for each, a company that wants its ledger under a licence it can keep running even if the vendor disappears. Of those, a marketplace splitting a single customer payment between seller, platform fee and tax that needs the split to be atomic and auditable and a fintech whose homegrown balances table produced numbers finance could not reconcile and now needs proper double-entry before an audit are not what Amazon Redshift ML is typically brought in for.
What can Formance do that Amazon Redshift ML cannot?
Formance covers Double-entry ledger, Numscript transaction DSL, Multi-currency, Payments connectivity. Amazon Redshift ML covers CREATE MODEL in SQL, Automatic model selection, Local inference, Bring your own model.

Answered from the vendors’ own pages

Formance: Is Formance really open source?

Yes. The core ledger is MIT licensed with full source access and no deployment restrictions.

Amazon Redshift ML: Does it require SageMaker?

Yes. Redshift ML is an interface; the training happens in SageMaker and needs an IAM role and an S3 bucket for the intermediate data.

Formance: Does Formance move money?

No. It records and orchestrates movements; the actual payments happen at a PSP or bank you connect.

Amazon Redshift ML: Is there an extra charge?

The SQL interface is part of Redshift, but the training runs as a SageMaker job charged at SageMaker rates, and a remote inference endpoint is billed for as long as it exists.

Formance: What does the enterprise version cost?

Not published. It is an annual subscription quoted per customer.

Amazon Redshift ML: What kinds of model can it build?

Regression, binary and multiclass classification through the automatic path, plus direct use of XGBoost, linear learner, multilayer perceptron and K-means. Anything beyond structured tabular prediction is out of scope.

Formance: Do I have to use Numscript?

Yes for anything beyond the simplest transfers. It is how multi-party transactions are expressed atomically.

Amazon Redshift ML: Can I use a model I trained myself?

Yes, through the bring-your-own-model path, either compiled into the cluster for local inference or called as a remote SageMaker endpoint.

Amazon Redshift ML: Does it retrain automatically?

No. Retraining means running CREATE MODEL again, on a schedule you build yourself, and nothing in the product monitors whether it is needed.

Share

Related pages

Other head to heads