Testing · head to head
Cucumber vs Windmill

Cucumber
Testing
Behaviour-driven development testing framework that returned to community ownership after nine years under SmartBear
- From
- Free
- Free plan
- Yes

Windmill
Automation Integration
Open-source developer platform for building scripts, workflows, and internal apps
- From
- Free
- Free plan
- Yes
The short version
- Cucumber is free; Windmill starts at $120/mo.
- Only Cucumber lists gherkin syntax; only Windmill lists script-to-workflow engine.
- Where Windmill falls short: free self-hosted tier caps SSO users at 10 and workspaces at 3, requiring Enterprise for larger teams.
- Prices and features on this page were last checked on 20 November 2026.
How do Cucumber and Windmill differ?
Cucumber and Windmill differ on pricing model, platforms and category. Only the attributes on which Cucumber and Windmill actually diverge.
Identical on both: starting price (Free), free tier (Yes).
Which features does each one have?
They share no listed features; 6 appear only for Cucumber and 6 only for Windmill. Drawn from each product's published feature list. An absence here means we hold no record of it - not that the product lacks it.
Only in Cucumber
- Gherkin syntax
- Step definition binding
- Multi-language support
- Living documentation
- Tagging and scenario outlines
- Reporting plugins
Only in Windmill
- Script-to-workflow engine
- Auto-generated UIs
- Self-hosted deployment
- Git sync
- SSO support
- Audit logs
What is each one used for?
Windmill is most often brought in for turning ad-hoc scripts into scheduled jobs and APIs. The jobs each tool is most often brought in to do.
Cucumber
- A team practising behaviour-driven development that wants shared, readable specifications between product owners and engineersnot Windmill
- An organisation wanting living documentation that stays synchronised with actual test coverage rather than a separate specification documentnot Windmill
- A QA team migrating acceptance tests from a proprietary BDD tool to an open source, community-governed alternativenot Windmill
- A Java, JavaScript or Ruby project needing a mature BDD framework rather than building Gherkin-style parsing from scratchnot Windmill
Windmill
- Turning ad-hoc scripts into scheduled jobs and APIsnot Cucumber
- Building internal tools from existing Python/TypeScript codenot Cucumber
- Self-hosted automation for engineering teamsnot Cucumber
- Orchestrating multi-language workflowsnot Cucumber
Where do Cucumber and Windmill fall short?
Windmill's most cited limit: free self-hosted tier caps SSO users at 10 and workspaces at 3, requiring Enterprise for larger teams. Documented limitations, not opinions. Every one is a constraint you would hit in normal use.
Cucumber
- Gherkin's plain-language layer adds a real maintenance burden, keeping feature files, step definitions and implementation code synchronised across a large suite is a known source of drift and duplicated effort
- Ownership has moved twice in under a decade, from independent to SmartBear-owned to independent community ownership again, which should temper confidence in any specific long-range roadmap claim
- Non-technical stakeholders who are meant to read and write Gherkin scenarios often do not engage with them in practice, leaving the readability benefit unrealised while the maintenance cost remains
- Step definition reuse across a large feature file set can become tangled, with ambiguous step matching causing hard-to-debug failures as a suite grows
- As a community-owned project without a corporate backer's support infrastructure, enterprise buyers wanting a formal support contract have no vendor to buy one from, unlike some competing BDD tools still sold commercially
Windmill
- Free self-hosted tier caps SSO users at 10 and workspaces at 3, requiring Enterprise for larger teams
- Compute unit and seat-based pricing (developer vs. operator seats, worker compute units) adds pricing complexity beyond a flat monthly fee
- Email triggers are capped at 100/day on the free tier, limiting event-driven use cases without upgrading
- Smaller ecosystem of pre-built integrations compared to more established automation tools like n8n
How much do Cucumber and Windmill cost?
Cucumber is free to use; Windmill has a free plan, with paid plans from $120/mo. Plan by plan below, from each vendor's own pricing page.
Cucumber
Free- CucumberFree
- Full functionality across Cucumber-JVM, Cucumber-JS, Cucumber-Ruby and other implementations
- Community support via GitHub
- Returned to independent community ownership in December 2024 after nine years connected to SmartBear
Windmill
Free- Free / Open-sourceFree
- Unlimited executions
- Self-hosted deployment
- Max 10 users with SSO
- Enterprise$120/mo
- Unlimited executions and workspaces
- Uncapped SSO seats
- 24/7 priority support (3-hour response)
Which should you pick?
Choose Cucumber if
- You need gherkin syntax.
- You want to start without paying.
- You work on Linux, macOS, Windows.
- You also want step definition binding.
Choose Windmill if
- You need script-to-workflow engine.
- You want to start without paying.
- You work on Web, API, Linux, Windows, macOS.
- You also want auto-generated uis.
Questions people ask
- Is Cucumber or Windmill better?
- Neither clearly leads. Cucumber starts at Free and Windmill at Free, and user ratings are close enough to be indistinguishable. Choose on capability and platform support.
- Which is cheaper, Cucumber or Windmill?
- Cucumber starts at Free and Windmill at Free.
- Does Cucumber or Windmill run on more platforms?
- Cucumber runs on Linux, macOS, Windows. Windmill runs on Web, API, Linux, Windows, macOS.
- Can I use Cucumber for free?
- Both have a free tier, so you can try either at no cost before committing.
- What is Cucumber best used for?
- Cucumber is most often used for a team practising behaviour-driven development that wants shared, readable specifications between product owners and engineers, an organisation wanting living documentation that stays synchronised with actual test coverage rather than a separate specification document, a qa team migrating acceptance tests from a proprietary bdd tool to an open source, community-governed alternative, a java, javascript or ruby project needing a mature bdd framework rather than building gherkin-style parsing from scratch. Of those, a team practising behaviour-driven development that wants shared, readable specifications between product owners and engineers and an organisation wanting living documentation that stays synchronised with actual test coverage rather than a separate specification document are not what Windmill is typically brought in for.
- What can Cucumber do that Windmill cannot?
- Cucumber covers Gherkin syntax, Step definition binding, Multi-language support, Living documentation. Windmill covers Script-to-workflow engine, Auto-generated UIs, Self-hosted deployment, Git sync.
Answered from the vendors’ own pages
Cucumber: Is Cucumber owned by SmartBear?
No, not currently. SmartBear acquired Cucumber Ltd in 2019 but the open source project returned to independent community ownership in December 2024.
Windmill: What does Windmill cost?
Windmill's Free and Open-source edition is $0/month for self-hosted use with unlimited executions, while Enterprise starts at $120/month with unlimited workspaces and uncapped SSO seats, priced further by developer/operator seats and compute units.
SourceCucumber: Is Cucumber free?
Yes, entirely open source with no licence fee across all its language implementations.
Windmill: Is there a free plan and what are its limits?
The free self-hosted plan supports unlimited executions but caps SSO at 10 users, workspaces at 3, groups/permissions at 4, and email triggers at 100 per day.
SourceCucumber: Does Cucumber replace Selenium or Appium?
No, Cucumber provides the Gherkin specification layer and step definition binding; the actual browser or mobile automation still needs a driver such as Selenium or Appium underneath.
Windmill: How is usage metered on Windmill Enterprise?
Enterprise usage is metered through seats (developer seats at $20/month, operator seats at $10/month) and compute units, e.g. $100/month for 2 standard-worker compute units.
SourceWindmill: What happens to a self-hosted Windmill deployment if the company shuts down?
The pricing page addresses this directly as an FAQ topic, noting that self-hosted applications built on the open-source edition can continue running independently of Windmill the company.
SourceRelated pages
Other head to heads
- Cucumber vs Robot Framework
- Cucumber vs Appium
- Cucumber vs Selenium
- Cucumber vs Xray Test Management
- Cucumber vs Testsigma
- Cucumber vs Applitools
- Cucumber vs JUnit
- Cucumber vs TestNG
- Cucumber vs Percy
- Cucumber vs GrowthBook
- Cucumber vs PractiTest
- Cucumber vs Qase
- Cucumber vs Zephyr Scale
- Cucumber vs Ranorex
- Cucumber vs Split
- Cucumber vs Detox
- Cucumber vs Jest
- Cucumber vs WebdriverIO
- Cucumber vs n8n
- Cucumber vs Temporal
- Cucumber vs Pipedream
- Cucumber vs Trigger.dev
- Cucumber vs Hatchet
- Cucumber vs Mage AI
- Cucumber vs Prefect
- Cucumber vs Nango
- Cucumber vs Airbyte
- Cucumber vs Meltano
- Cucumber vs Flowable
- Cucumber vs RudderStack
- Cucumber vs Nintex
- Cucumber vs Camunda
- Cucumber vs Dify
- Cucumber vs Hevo Data
- Cucumber vs SnapLogic
- Cucumber vs Hightouch
- Windmill vs Robot Framework
- Windmill vs Appium
- Windmill vs Selenium
- Windmill vs Xray Test Management
- Windmill vs Testsigma
- Windmill vs Applitools
- Windmill vs JUnit
- Windmill vs TestNG
- Windmill vs Percy
- Windmill vs GrowthBook
- Windmill vs PractiTest
- Windmill vs Qase
- Windmill vs Zephyr Scale
- Windmill vs Ranorex
- Windmill vs Split
- Windmill vs Detox
- Windmill vs Jest
- Windmill vs WebdriverIO
- Windmill vs n8n
- Windmill vs Temporal
- Windmill vs Pipedream
- Windmill vs Trigger.dev
- Windmill vs Hatchet
- Windmill vs Mage AI
- Windmill vs Prefect
- Windmill vs Nango
- Windmill vs Airbyte
- Windmill vs Meltano
- Windmill vs Flowable
- Windmill vs RudderStack
- Windmill vs Nintex
- Windmill vs Camunda
- Windmill vs Dify
- Windmill vs Hevo Data
- Windmill vs SnapLogic
- Windmill vs Hightouch
